Imagine that you are in your kitchen at home, cooking a great meal. As you reach out to your cooking oil, you pause. Do you use the animal fat sitting on your countertop or do you use the vegetable oil bottle? So many people are faced with this problem nowadays. Between the long debate on which kind of oil is much healthier, how would you actually know which suits your needs regarding health and cooking?
When it comes to the oils, be it animal fat oils or vegetable oils, both have been a part and parcel of kitchens for centuries. And if the cup has been spilling over on both sides of the glass, so to speak, then the best and the worst have equalized to be achieved and sometimes seemed a little heavy-handed to compare one against another. In this article, we are going to dig into the details of both for you to know which one is considered the healthier one used for cooking.
On the contrary, there are so many cooking oils. From lard and tallow of ancient civilizations to newer olive and canola oils, the list would seem endless. As global knowledge regarding heart health, sustainability, and nutrition becomes more extensive, the debate still rages as to which is better: animal fat oils or vegetable oils. In this blog, we are going to outline the health benefits and issues of each in hopes of helping you make informed choices in your kitchen.
Understanding Animal Fat Oils
What are Animal Fat Oils? Animal fat oils, derived from animal fats, have enhanced many cuisines for thousands of years. They encompass lard, pork; tallow, beef or mutton; duck fat, and clarified butter, also known as ghee. These oils had historical acceptance due to their strong flavors, and they could reach baking temperatures at extremes. Lard, for instance, was part of most traditional recipes before it became a norm to start using vegetable oil.
Nutritional Profile of Animal Fat Oils. Animal fats are saturated with saturated fats and monounsaturated fats. Saturated fats were once blamed for causing some mischief they supposedly cause to our health, but the latest findings of some recent studies also revealed the possibility that they may not be so terrible after all. Do remember that animal fats, such as lard, are a source of vitamins A, D, and K-fat-soluble vitamins with very important functions in your body. Don't forget, however, that animal fats are extremely, extremely calorie-dense.
Understanding Vegetable Oils
What Are Vegetable Oils? Vegetable oils are extracted from the seed, nut, or fruit of any plant. Among those, some of the majorly used vegetable oils include olive oil, canola oil, sunflower oil, and coconut oil. The vegetable oils are relatively a new source of substitution to animal fats and are held to be heart-friendly as they contain more amounts of unsaturated fats.
Nutritional Content of Vegetable Oils. Vegetable oils contain polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fats, which are heart-friendly. For example, oleic acid content in olive oil may be one possible monounsaturated fat capable of reducing inflammation, and thus also reducing the risks associated with heart disease. Omega-3 fatty acids, mostly derived from flaxseed oil, are known as an important constituent of brain and heart health. Vegetable oils are not all created equal; processed vegetable oils such as soybean oil have unhealthy trans fats; therefore it's best to be either cold-pressed or unrefined.
Check out some options at our store!
Health Benefits of Animal Fat Oils
Saturated Fats and Their Role in Health. While saturated fats had long been considered unhealthy, studies now claim that they make one feel full and also provide the body with fat-soluble vitamins. More so, some such as tallow and duck fat have a weird taste, making them great for roasting or frying. To those who are on keto diets or paleo, animal fat oils are great because they are full of fatty nutrients.
Potential Benefits of Animal-Derived Nutrients. Animal fats do contain fat-soluble vitamins, which are important for bone strength and will also contribute to the development of the immune system. As an example, ghee is a source of vitamin K2, which is essential in metabolizing calcium. So, animal fats may have anti-inflammatory effects and help those consumers desire to avoid pro-inflammatory foods.
Health Effects of Vegetable Oils
Omega-3, Omega-6s and Omega-9, and Heart Health. Its high points are the contents that have unsaturated fats, which is said to reduce low-density lipoprotein or bad cholesterol and increase high-density lipoprotein or good cholesterol. Olive oil is part of the Mediterranean diet and quite well known to be good for one's heart. Flaxseed and walnut oils are full of omega-3s, which the brain needs and also utilizes in terms of fighting inflammation.
Antioxidant and Nutrient Content. Fat vegetable oil, as is extra virgin olive oil, is rich in antioxidants that protect the human body from oxidative stress and inflammation. These oils can be natural sources of vitamin E and polyphenols that may retard the rates of chronic diseases, such as cancer and heart diseases.
Possible Negative Effect of Animal Fat Oils
Issues with Saturated Fats. Although high intakes are not as detrimental to us as was once thought, they can also be injurious and considerably increase the risk of heart disease, even in already diagnosed heart patients. Other claims argue that excessive saturated intake increases only cholesterol and that intake of animal fats must be reduced.
Sustainability and Ethical Implications. Other environmental issue is the use of animal fat oils. Animal agriculture is a resource-hungry activity; most people would like to opt for vegetable oils for ethical and environmental reasons. So, if sustainability is your concern, then the choice of vegetable oils would be your option.
Defects of Vegetable Oils
Highly Processed Vegetable Oils. Not all vegetable oils are the same. Highly processed oils, such as soybean and corn oil, often have refining processes that remove any nutrients from the oil. In the worst cases, they even include trans fats, contributing to an unhealthy heart. Where possible, seek out cold-pressed or extra virgin options.
Omega-6 Imbalance. Many of the vegetable oils, including sunflower oil and corn oil, contain too much omega-6. Omega-6 is necessary but excessive, without an adequate amount of omega-3s, which causes an inflammatory reaction. To avoid being imbalanced, combine them with oils and consume sources that have good amounts of omega-3s. These include flaxseed and walnut.
Cooking with Animal Fat Oils vs. Vegetable Oils
Best Uses of Animal Fat Oils. Lard, tallow, and duck fat are among the top animal fats used for frying and roasting. For high-temperature dishes, these are very good because they have very high smoke points. They also bring great savory flavors to dishes.
Best Uses of Vegetable Oils. These vegetable oils are appropriate for low temperature finishes, or cooking within dressings, sauces and baking. Coconut oil is very flavorful and contains medium chain fatty acids, making it appropriate for cooking as well as baking.
They are great at sautéing and roasting since they have high smoke points and strong flavors. But do not forget that they belong to the saturated fats category, so be moderate with their use.
Making the Healthiest Choice for Your Cooking Needs
When to Use Vegetable Oils. These oils have a greater percentage of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats and are generally the better choices for heart health. Use olive and avocado oils sparingly for dressings and other light cooking. Flaxseed oil may be used to provide enough omega-3s. These oils will add to an overall healthy diet and create a long-term benefit.
Finding Balance in Your Kitchen. So, for example, you can have your animal fat oils and your vegetable oils in the kitchen-whichever one best suits your needs and your cooking style. You can have a little bit of everything and still benefit from the best of both worlds.
On a Final Note…
No one can generalize arguments about animal fats oils versus vegetable oils. Sometimes, each seems to have its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Your healthiest choice will depend on your individual health goals as well as your cooking preference. Although you may need to crave the rich, savory flavor of animal fats or prefer heart-healthy benefits from vegetable oils, moderation must be observed.
Like this? Try both! For pure animal fat and vegetable oils, check out The Epicurean Trader, good for making your creations in the kitchen much more varied!
Want to know even more posts and learn tips on moderation cooking? Read more at our Epicurean Trader blog!
So overall we have discussed that, animal fat oils and vegetable oils have a long debate in them; where the other may offer great health benefits, the drawback is unique to it. Animal fat oils include lard and tallow, saturated fats, and fat-soluble vitamins A and D. These can be used at high heats, but too much will raise the cholesterol. While vegetable oils, for example, olive and flaxseed oil, are rich in unsaturated fats and omega-3 fatty acids that promote good cardiovascular health, their processed counterparts may contain unsafe trans fats. Choosing an option to cook requires reconciling healthy options with taste buds; after all, you are balancing both the poles.
